Today I'm going to give you some background theories about probable origins of the finger crossing superstition. I will then try to give you an example of how crossing our fingers for luck or to annul the white lie that we told. After that I will analyze the story and an extra scenario so that you can see what I'm talking about with superstitions playing a part in the fallacies in our logic and reasoning.
The next theory that WiseGeek talks about is one of my favorites. It deals with secret societies and just seems to resemble one of my favorite games Assassin's Creed about a secret society. Christianity became an outlawed religion during it's early history. It's followers had to form a secret society and to protect their identities they had to develop secret hand signs to be able to recognize each other. Talk about insanely cool!! I mean it would be horrible to have to resort to secret meeting in order to avoid getting caught and quite possibly tortured. But the idea of secret societies and conspiracies makes interesting fodder for a fantasy novel (keeping that idea for later).
Another theory that interested me was when a possible origin of the modern day version of crossing fingers was mentioned starting up around the time of the Hundred Years War from 1337 to 1457. Individuals on both sides of the army needed all the luck they could get and archers would have crossed his fingers and quickly prayed before pulling the bowstring back. Why do you think the archer would cross their fingers? Was it for good luck so that they would hit their target? Perhaps once while they crossed their fingers and shot they hit the intended target so they figured it would continuously do so, turning it into a superstition.
To break away from the theories of luck and warding off evil, most of us as children would cross our fingers when telling a "white lie". According to Wikipedia, this could have sprung up from the belief that the "Christian cross"could possibly save a person who told a lie from going to hell. Which brings me to the next thing I would like to address about fallacies and superstitions affecting logic. I would like to help illustrate how superstitions such as finger crossing play into our logic and reasoning by sharing a short story I wrote. Try to see if you can see some fallacies and superstitions.
As I'm walking home from school, I know I'm toast. I know mom is going to ask me how the test went. I thought I did so well, how could I have failed? If mom finds out, I'm grounded and have to miss the school dance. Maybe she won't ask and I won't have to tell her. Even if she does ask, I don't really have to tell her do I? I pause on our stairs with my hand on the door. I mean what she doesn't know can't hurt her right? Plus I will make sure to do better on the next test to help boost my grade back up. All of this bad luck I'm having all because I walked under that ladder last week. How will I survive seven years bad luck? It won't really last that long will it?
I hear mom vacuuming the living room so maybe I can sneak past her. I quietly step into the entryway and close the door as silently as I can. I slide my shoes off and peak into the living room. Mom has her back turned so here's my chance. Sliding across the hall, I hasten upstairs to my room. I get into my room and I hear the vacuum shut off. Dog gone it! She heard me on the stairs. She calls up to my room but I put my headphones in so I can't hear her. I pull out my chemistry book just in time. Mom opens my door and motions for me to pull out my headphones.
"How'd your test go honey?"
I brace myself and put my headphones down. What should I say? Before I know it, my mouth started talking before my "filter" could kick in. "Oh, it went good. It was a hard test but studying helped." I replied with my fingers crossed hidden from mom's view.
She smiled at me. "That's great! You can still go to the dance tomorrow. Just wait, I got you something." She disappears from my sight. How could I lie to her? But... it's not like I'm hurting anyone. I mean, it's not like I killed someone. All I did was tell a little white lie. What could go wrong?
Mom came back hiding something out of my view. "You know that dress you wanted to get this weekend? Well, I went back and picked it up just in case you passed." She was beaming.
I felt horrible. "That's great mom."
Did you notice all of superstitions and fallacies in logic in this story? Did you notice how the main character justified lying to her mom by saying it wouldn't hurt her? Well physically, no it wouldn't but it would hurt emotionally that her daughter had lied to her. Did you also notice that the daughter crossed her fingers when she lied, and still as a teen she thought that it would cancel out her lie? The daughter also blamed walking under a ladder as the main cause for her failing a test rather than take the blame herself for not studying or being prepared. And to the daughter, this seemed to be logically sound. We know better and can see this for the fallacy in logic it actually is.
So why do we still cross our fingers for luck or to "cancel" a promise? Why do we still practice other superstitions like black cats? We know that superstitions such as this can affect our logic yet we still do them. BF Skinner, a behavioral psychologist, studying supposed superstitious behavior in pigeons. His theory has been adapted to explain superstition in humans. Basically this would mean that we continue to practice or "believe" in superstitions because of two main reasons: 1) the person thinks that by continuously practicing the superstition it will eventually work; or 2) the practice of the superstition has coincided with an event or result and could continue to do so either at random or continuously. Which makes sense if it happened as a child. If I'm remembering correctly, I observed someone else crossing their fingers in several instances and as a kid I thought that it was magic because they seemed to always get what they wanted. And as a child, we are extremely influenced easily by what we see or hear.
So why do we still cross our fingers for luck or to "cancel" a promise? Why do we still practice other superstitions like black cats? We know that superstitions such as this can affect our logic yet we still do them. BF Skinner, a behavioral psychologist, studying supposed superstitious behavior in pigeons. His theory has been adapted to explain superstition in humans. Basically this would mean that we continue to practice or "believe" in superstitions because of two main reasons: 1) the person thinks that by continuously practicing the superstition it will eventually work; or 2) the practice of the superstition has coincided with an event or result and could continue to do so either at random or continuously. Which makes sense if it happened as a child. If I'm remembering correctly, I observed someone else crossing their fingers in several instances and as a kid I thought that it was magic because they seemed to always get what they wanted. And as a child, we are extremely influenced easily by what we see or hear.
You can't make fun of people who are very superstitious because most people still hold onto some superstition - consciously or unconsciously regardless of good or bad reasoning. This could range anywhere from finger crossing to avoiding stepping on cracks to ways of breaking the hex like knocking on wood, etc. Here is a video of two comedians and their take on superstitions.
While this video is funny, it shows how superstitions can contribute to fallacies in logic and reasoning. For example, they believe all the things that go wrong (towel on the floor, interrupting the breaking of a hex, breaking a mirror, black cat) can affect the basketball game they are about to play. The are a bit extreme in the lengths they go to "break the hexes" but this is a comedic sketch. But some people who are this superstitious could go to the same lengths. Can you now name some superstitions you still hold on to? Do you notice it affecting your judgement in any way?